BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES
Governing Board of the Los Angeles Unified School District
SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES
450 North Grand Avenue, Room H-160
3:30 p.m., Tuesday, March 19, 2002
The Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles, acting as the Governing Board of the Los Angeles
Unified School District, met in special session on Tuesday, March 19, 2002, in Room H-160, Los Angeles
City Board of Education Administrative Offices, 450 North Grand Avenue.
President Caprice Young called the meeting to order at 4:15 a.m.
The following Board Members were present: Ms. Marlene Canter, Mr. José Huizar, Ms. Julie Korenstein,
and President Caprice Young. Mr. David Tokofsky arrived at 4:16 p.m., Mr. Mike Lansing at 4:17 p.m.
and Ms. Genethia Hudley Hayes arrived at 4:20 p.m.
Mr. Huizar led the Pledge of Allegiance.
- - - -
President Young modified the Order of Business and passed the gavel to Ms. Canter.
- - - -
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS FOR ACTION
Mr. Huizar moved a waiver of Board Rule 72 to allow action on the following motion regarding Monsignor
Oscar Romero. Ms. Young seconded the motion, which by general consent was adopted. Ms. Hayes and
Mr. Lansing were absent.
Ms. Young moved:
Whereas, Msgr. Oscar A. Romero was ordained as a priest on April 4, 1942, in Rome;
- Whereas, Msgr. Oscar A. Romero was assigned to Anamoros, La Union in El Salvador on
August 15, 1943, and became Secretary of Msgr. Miguel Angel Machado, Archbishop of
San Miguel;
- Whereas, Msgr. Oscar A. Romero was appointed as the General Secretary of the Episcopal
Conference of El Salvador in 1966 and appointed as the Executive Secretary of the Episcopal
Counsel of Central America and Panama in 1967;
- Whereas, Msgr. Oscar A. Romero was appointed Assistant Bishop of San Salvador on May 3, 1970,
appointed Bishop of Santiago de Maria, Usulutan on October 15, 1974, and appointed Archbishop of
San Salvador and officially assumed his position on February 22, 1977;
- Whereas, Msgr. Oscar A. Romero was awarded the doctorate Honoris Causa from Lovaina,
University of Belgium and was awarded the doctorate Honoris Causa from Georgetown University;
and
- Whereas, Msgr. Oscar A. Romero was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize, for his Human Rights
struggles; now, therefore, be it
- Resolved, That the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles recognize Msgr. Oscar A. Romero
for his outstanding service and dedication for the people of El Salvador; his legacy and his fight on
behalf of the poor, and against injustice, lives stronger than ever; and be it
- Resolved further, That the Board of Education declares March 24th as Msgr. Oscar A. Romero Day.
Mr. Huizar seconded the motion, which by general consent was adopted.
Ms. Young presented Luke Williams and Mary López from Clínica Romero with a certificate of
recognition for their services to the community. Mr. Williams and Ms. López thanked Board Members
for recognizing the work of Msgr. Romero and the clinic, which is located in the Pico Union area of
Los Angeles.
- - - -
President Young assumed the Chair and resumed the Order of Business.
- - - -
DIRECT REPORTS
BOARD OF EDUCATION REPORT NO. 1
This item was withdrawn prior to the meeting.
BOARD OF EDUCATION REPORT NO. 2
Authorization to Negotiate and Enter into a Contract for Energy Services
Mr. Lansing moved that the report be adopted. Ms. Canter seconded the motion.
Mr. Harold Kwalwasser, General Counsel, Mr. Andrew Cheung, Assistant General Counsel, and Mr. Ken
Davis, Energy Manager, responded to questions by Board Members.
After discussion, staff indicated they would communicate to registered providers the District's plan to seek
suppliers for energy services.
By general consent, the report was adopted.
- - - -
President Young recognized representatives from the Oakland Unified School District, who are looking at
the District's Open Court Reading Program implementation.
- - - -
BOARD OF EDUCATION REPORT NO. 3
Student Expulsions
Ms. Korenstein moved that the report be adopted. Ms. Canter seconded the motion, which by general
consent was adopted. Mr. Tokofsky was absent.
Later in the meeting, Mr. Tokofsky recorded an aye vote on the report.
BOARD OF EDUCATION REPORT NO. 4
Student Reinstatements
Ms. Canter moved that the report be adopted. Mr. Lansing seconded the motion, which by general consent
was adopted. Mr. Tokofsky was absent.
Later in the meeting, Mr. Tokofsky recorded an aye vote on the report.
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS FOR ACTION (Continued)
Ms. Canter's motions regarding Surplus Property and the Lease of Collier and Collins Elementary School
were separated into two individual motions.
The following speakers addressed the Board:
Ms. Liz Koenig-Golombek shared her time with Deborah Thompson
Ms. Monica Witt in place of Ben Reznick
Ms. Phillis Hanken, in place of Deborah Rosenberg, shared her time with Hector Carrillo
Ms. Cheri Mayman
Ms. Kim Shirley shared her time with Deborah Rosenberg and Bita Makanvand
Ms. Debbie Dershowitz
Mr. William Bloom
Motion 1 - Surplus Properties
Ms. Canter moved:
- Whereas, the Los Angeles Unified School District faces a shortage of seats for its students, and the
closed schools in the San Fernando Valley represent an opportunity to build seats quickly and at
low cost;
- Whereas, the District has a shortage of capital for its building program and has committed scarce
resources to the Priority Plan;
- Whereas, Charter Schools and turnkey developments represent viable financing and construction
options for building public schools;
- Whereas, Charter schools can prioritize students from overcrowded areas and have done so in the
past; now, therefore be it
- Resolved
, that the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles instruct the Superintendent to
provide within 45 days:
- 1. An analysis of the options for conversion of the following campuses into high schools,
including the possibilities of joint use agreements with independent charter high schools with
the requirement that any such school would give priority to students from
overcrowded areas
capped schools:
Platt Ranch Elementary School
Hesby Street Elementary School
Charles E. Hughes Middle School (including an option for Joint Use
with existing Adult School)
- 2. An analysis of the options for conversion of Oso Avenue Elementary School into a joint use
District Special Education Professional Development Center and full-inclusion Special
Education independent charter school;
- Resolved
further, That the Superintendent shall provide to the Board a 5 year action plan for the
following closed properties within 30 days:
Enadia Way School
Devonshire Elementary School
Highlander Way Elementary School
Mr. Lansing seconded the motion.
Mr. James McConnell, Chief Facilities Executive, and Mr. Scott Graham from the Facilities Services
responded to questions by Board Members.
Mr. Tokofsky moved the following amendment:
1. An analysis of the options for conversion of the following campuses into high schools,
including the possibilities of joint use agreements with independent charter high schools with
the requirement that any such school would give priority to students from overcrowded areas
and schools participating in the Capacity Adjustment Program:
Platt Ranch Elementary School
Hesby Street Elementary School
Charles E. Hughes Middle School (including an option for Joint Use with
existing Adult School)
The maker and seconder accepted it as a friendly amendment.
Ms. Korenstein moved the following amendment:
1. An analysis of the options for conversion of the following campuses into high schools,
including the possibilities of joint use agreements with independent charter high schools with
the requirement that any such school would give priority to students from overcrowded areas
and schools participating in the Capacity Adjustment Program:
Platt Ranch Elementary School
Hesby Street Elementary School
Charles E. Hughes Middle School (including an option for Joint Use
with existing Adult School or placement at another closed site)
The maker and seconder accepted it as a friendly amendment.
By general consent, the motion was adopted as amended.
The final motion reads:
1. Surplus Properties
- Whereas, the Los Angeles Unified School District faces a shortage of seats for its students, and
the closed schools in the San Fernando Valley represent an opportunity to build seats quickly
and at low cost;
- Whereas, the District has a shortage of capital for its building program and has committed
scarce resources to the Priority Plan;
- Whereas, Charter Schools and turnkey developments represent viable financing and
construction options for building public schools;
- Whereas, Charter schools can prioritize students from overcrowded areas and have done so in
the past; now, therefore be it
- Resolved
, that the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles instruct the Superintendent to
provide within 45 days:
- 1. An analysis of the options for conversion of the following campuses into high schools,
including the possibilities of joint use agreements with independent charter high schools
with the requirement that any such school would give priority to students from overcrowded
areas and schools participating in the Capacity Adjustment Program:
Platt Ranch Elementary School
Hesby Street Elementary School
Charles E. Hughes Middle School (including an option for Joint Use
with existing Adult School or placement at another closed site)
- 2. An analysis of the options for conversion of Oso Avenue Elementary School into a joint use
District Special Education Professional Development Center and full-inclusion Special
Education independent charter school;
- Resolved
further, That the Superintendent shall provide to the Board a 5 year action plan for
the following closed properties within 30 days:
Enadia Way School
Devonshire Elementary School
Highlander Way Elementary School
Motion 2 - Lease of Collier Street and Collins Elementary Schools
Ms. Canter moved:
Resolved, That the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles immediately declare as surplus
property Collier Street Elementary School and Collins Elementary Street School; and be it
- Resolved, that the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles, having previously declared
Collier Elementary School and Collins Elementary School as Surplus Property, instructs the
Superintendent to issue a Request for Proposals to lease both Collier Street Elementary School and
Collins Street Elementary School on the following terms, having previously resolved price and other
terms in closed session:
- A term (the "Lease Term") initially consisting of ten (10) years; provided, however, the Los
Angeles Unified School District may elect to terminate the lease as of the first day of the sixth (6th)
lease year by providing the tenant with at least two (2) year's prior written notice of such election;
provided further, however, that such Lease Term shall automatically renew for two (2) five (5) year
periods, unless either tenant or the District notifies the other party in writing at least two (2) years
prior to the date each such option term would commence. Staff will notify the Board at least 90
days prior to the District allowing the lease to continue for any successive 5-year period after the
initial 5-year period and shall receive Board approval to allow such continuance
.
Mr. Tokofsky seconded the motion.
Mr. Graham responded to concerns expressed by Board Members.
After discussion and on roll call, the motion was adopted as amended 5 ayes, 2 noes, Ms. Hayes,
Ms. Korenstein.
The final motion reads:
- Resolved,
that the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles, having previously declared
Collier Elementary School and Collins Elementary School as Surplus Property, instructs the
Superintendent to issue a Request for Proposals to lease both Collier Street Elementary School and
Collins Street Elementary School on the following terms, having previously resolved price and other
terms in closed session:
A term (the "Lease Term") initially consisting of ten (10) years; provided, however, the
Los Angeles Unified School District may elect to terminate the lease as of the first day of the sixth
(6th) lease year by providing the tenant with at least two (2) year's prior written notice of such
election; provided further, however, that such Lease Term shall automatically renew for two (2) five
(5) year periods, unless either tenant or the District notifies the other party in writing at least two
(2) years prior to the date each such option term would commence. Staff will notify the Board at
least 90 days prior to the District allowing the lease to continue for any successive 5-year period
after the initial 5-year period and shall receive Board approval to allow such continuance.
Ms. Hayes moved a waiver of Board Rules 72, 191, and any other Board Rules necessary simultaneously
with the following motion:
- Resolved
, That the Board of Education reconsider its action taken on March 12, 2002, regarding her
motion on Reality Based Learning.
Mr. Huizar seconded the motion, which by general consent was adopted.
The following addressed the Board on the motion regarding Reality Based Learning originally adopted
March 12, 2002:
Mr. Dafer Dakhil
Mr. Howard Watts
Ms. Hayes withdrew her motion regarding Reality Based Learning:
- Whereas, Proposition 227 approved by the voters mandates that funds be used to teach adults the
English language;
- Whereas, The Los Angeles Unified School District is authorized to administer the funds for the
Community Based English Tutoring Program (C-BET);
- Whereas, Adults having acquired English language skills are required to tutor children as a criteria
for receiving C-BET funding;
- Whereas, The District has received over $45 million in C-BET funding from the State;
- Whereas, C-BET funding is allocated for this year and the District will be provided funds on an
average of $11 million for the next three years (2002, 2003, 2004) as required by Proposition 227;
- Whereas, Expanding the availability of services to acquired English language skills is in the interest
of all parties concerned;
- Whereas, It is understood by the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles that access to
English as a Second Language (ESL) programs is not being offered to the extent necessary to meet
the demand within the City of Los Angeles. Furthermore, let it be understood that current programs
being offered by the District adult schools are not successful in satisfying the growing need, this
new technology is now required to serve the public need and provide for program accountability at a
cost below our current return on investment; now, therefore, be it
- Resolved, That the Los Angeles Unified School District provide $3.3 million in funding from
2001-02 C-BET state funds that will live up to the law and intent of Proposition 227 to develop an
internet based English Learning Program on a pilot project basis. The program development must
commence development on April 19, 2002, and begin implementation of the internet by June 1,
2002, in seven adult schools and the communities they serve; and be it
- Resolved, further That an additional $1 million per year in C-BET funds be committed for the next
three years (2002, 2003, 2004) to ensure continued program success and modifications; and be it
finally
- Resolved, That the District central office staff be instructed to issue a purchase order based on the
submitted scope of work by Reality Based Learning California by April 19, 2002.
MEETING, CONFERENCE, AND CONVENTION MOTIONS
AND ANNOUNCEMENTS
Mr. Tokofsky announced his intention to introduce the following motion:
- Resolved
,That the Board of Education of the City of Los Angeles authorize the Office of the
Inspector General to investigate all Los Angeles Unified School District expenditures since the
passing of Proposition 227 concerning C-BET funds; and be it
Resolved further, That the Superintendent or his designee present to the Board on or before May 1,
2002, a comprehensive report of all adult English as a Second Language (ESL) programs in the
District; and be it
Resolved further, That the Superintendent or his designee evaluate the effectiveness and
thoroughness of these adult ESL programs with particular regard to the current use and future
potential of computer assisted instruction; and be it finally
Resolved, that the Board authorize the Superintendent to initiate and complete an RFP process by
June 15, 2002, to fulfil areas of need within the District adult ESL instruction programs with
particular emphasis on the incorporation of computer assisted instruction.
Ms. Canter moved:
- That Mr. David Tokofsky, Member of this Board of Education, be found absent due to illness at the
time of the March 9, 2002, Special Board Meeting, and that Ms. Genethia Hudley Hayes, also a
Member of this Board, be found on Board business at the time of the Special and Closed Session
Board Meetings of March 14, 2002.
Ms. Korenstein seconded the motion, which by general consent was adopted.
Mr. Jefferson Crain, Executive Officer of the Board, announced:
- A public hearing was announced regarding the Economic Impact Aid (EIA) waiver for the Board
meeting today. We will take all public speakers on this subject. We will be holding the public
hearing on the EIA waiver at the Board meeting on Tuesday, April 23, 2002. The Board will take
action on the waiver at the meeting on April 23.
There were no speakers.
On motion by Ms. Hayes, seconded by Mr. Lansing, the meeting adjourned by general consent at
6:03 p.m.
APPROVED BY THE BOARD: April 9, 2002
__________________________________ ____________________________________
CAPRICE YOUNG JEFFERSON CRAIN
PRESIDENT EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF THE BOARD