If you would like to view Mr. Bobrosky's reviews from past
years, click here
MR. BOBROSKY'S REVIEWS 2002
MR. BOBROSKY'S REVIEWS 2003
Below is the current list of what Mr. Bobrosky has read
in 2004, with his review and rating.
5 = An absolute must read --- 4 = Very good,
highly recommended --- 3 = Enjoyable --- 2 = Passable ---
1 = Don't bother
The First Part Last by Angela Johnson (3.5)
Printz Award Winner
The topic of teen pregnancy is covered from the point of view of the father,
in this case, sixteen year old Bobby. A realistic and touching view of
how fatherhood changes Bobby's life in expected and unexpected ways. What
I liked is that Bobby is middle class with a solid and supportive family,
rather than the stereotypical underprivlidged or troubled youth that typifies
this genre.
Brian's Hunt by Gary Paulsen (2)
This book is overidden with details about surviving in the wilderness.
I felt that the author was putting forth his justification for hunting
rather than writing a good story. I did not enjoy this book. The story,
another sequel to Hatchet, has Brian returning to the wilderness.
We learn how Brian is an expert at survival and the hunt, He finds a dog,
determines it belongs to his Cree friends, goes to visit them and finds
their campground empty. Brian then embarks on a "hunt" to unravel
the mystery.
The Tale of Despereaux by Kate DiCamillo
(5) Newbery Award Winner
A beautifully told tale of a young mouse who commits the mortal sin of
having contact with the human world. Even more condemning is that he has
fallen madly in love with a human, Princess Pea. The mouse council finds
him guilty and sends him to the dungeon to be eaten by rats. This is just
the beginning of a tale that is so beautifully written. Every word is
perfectly chosen. This is one to enjoy, savor, and read aloud over and
over again!
Touching Spirit Bear by Ben Mikaelson (4.5)
Cole Matthews has been in serious trouble his whole life. Now, after brutally
beating a boy to the point that he causes severe brain damage, he must
pay the price. He is given a choice to either face the criminal justice
system, or face Circle Justice; a Native American tradition that gives
the victum and the offender an opportunity to heal. His sentence is to
spend one year on a desolate Alaskan island. Cole thinks that his sentence
is light, and can easily be escaped. His anger and attitude have not changed...until
he meets "Spirtit Bear". I read this book relunctanly, perhaps
it was the title that turned me off. The surprise was how much I enjoyed
it. Read it for the adventure, but also read it for the insights into
human nature.
The Glass Café by Gary Paulsen (4)
Tony is a gifted artist. His mother,Al, is an ideal parent. She is loving,
supportive, yet firm in her relationship with Tony. The only catch is
that she is a dancer at an adult club. Tony is given the chance to draw
some ot the other girls that work with his mother. When his art teacher
sees the pictures, she deems them so outstanding, she enters them into
an art contest. A complaint is filed because the pictures are because
the pictures are judged as pornographic. Social Services come to take
Tony from his mother...which is where the real story starts. The book
is fresh, fun, and takes a serious look at the social service system.
ChaseR: a novel in emails by Michael J.
Rosen (3)
Chase Riley's parents have decided to leave urban Columbus and move to
a rural farm. Disconnected from his friends, he communicates with them
by email. The story is told through his emails, which tell of a world
shockingly different than the one he came from. The inscects, the mice,
the deer, and the hunting season all present a different reality for Chase.
A reality he is learning to live with, until an accident happens.... The
story was interesting but not compelling. The novelty of the email format
was not enough to hold my interest. Just an o.k. read.
Flavor of the Week by Tucker Shaw (3)
Cyril is a high school senior, an outstanding chef, overweight, and madly
in love with Rose. Rose sees Cyril as a good friend. Cyril's best friend
Nick meets and falls for Rose. Nick asks Cyril to prepare a romantic meal
for Rose. Here the Cyrano-like charade begins as Rose falls head over
heels for Nick, believing he is a sensitive guy that can cook and be romantic.
The most interesting part of the book are the recipes at the end of each
chapter. I have to try the Kitchen-Sink cookies, and the roasted vegetable
sandwich.
Inside Out by Terry Trueman (5)
Zach is meeting his mother in the diner as usual. Two sixteen-year-olds
decide to rob the diner, and hold its patrons as hostage. What they don't
know is that Zach is a suicidal schizophrenic. He has little understanding
of what is happening and is constantly haunted by strange voices in his
head. Through Zach we find out why these boys are robbing the diner, and
the help they seek. A powerful story, told through Zach's eyes.
Granny Torelli Makes Soup by Sharon Creech
(4)
Rosie and Granny are in the kitchen making soup. You can feel the warmth
and smell the smells. But Granny senses something is wrong with Rosie.
Granny is able to get Rosie to reveal that she has had a falling out with
her best-frient-for-life, Bailey. There are many lessons here about friendship
and loyalty all told in Granny's kitchen.
Green Angel by Alice Hoffman (4)
Green is a quiet 16 year-old who witnesses the destruction of her family,
when they are killed in a 9/11 like tragedy. She changes, becoming dark
as the despair, grief, and lonliness sets in. She expresses herself through
the tatoos she carves into her skin and the thorned clothes she wears.
While depressed by the anarchy and emptiness around her, she eventually
sees hope and renewal. This book has been extremely popular with students,
both boys and girls.
The DaVinci Code by Dan Brown (4.5)
I felt this best-seller might be of interest to
our more mature readers. A murder-mystery-thriller involving the Priory
Sion, and ancient secret society, and Opus Dei, a fundamental Catholic
order. One of those can't put it down thrillers. While sex is implied,
there are no direct scenes, and the language is relatively mild. If a
reader can handle the length, and is interested in the subject matter,
why not?
What Would Joey Do? by Jack Gantos (5)
Sadly, this is the last book of the Joey Pigza trilogy. Joey is a good-hearted
young man who has his ADHD (hyperactiviy) under control. In this book
you meet Olivia, a blind girl that Joey is being home-schooled with. Olivia
is mean and has it in for Joey. Joey must also deal with the wacky, selfish,
and screwed up parents. The only person who centers his life is granny.
If you have read the other Joey Pigza books, this is a must read. If you
haven't read any of the Joey books, what are you waiting for?
Tru Confessions by Janet Tashjian
(3.5)
How could a devoted sister find a cure for her mentally
handicapped little brother by shooting a video? That is what 12 year old
Tru (short for Trudy) attempts to do when she finds out a local cable
station is accepting entries for ideas for a possible T.V. show. Tru decides
to follow her developmentaly handicapped brother with a video camera to
record his daily life. Tru learns about her brother,
his handicap, and complexities of life in this light hearted look at a
serious subject. I know many students will enjoy the humor and the journal
format of this book. For me, the story was a bit simplistic, but the humor
will have appeal for many students.
Emako Blue by Brenda Woods (4)
Emako is a beautiful, bright and talented high school senior
that is brutally murdered by gangs in central L.A. Her story is told in
the five different voices of friends attending her funeral. A poignant
story that forces us to look at the effects that senseless murder has
upon our youth. The voices range from painful sorrow to cold indifference.
Shakespeare Bats Cleanup by Ron Koertge
(4)
Most of the novels (at least the ones I've read) that use the free verse
format are written in a female voice. This book is a rare one, not only
because it is written in a male voice, but because it also explores different
forms of poetry. An English teacher could use this novel as a spring board
for a poetry unit. Kevin Boland is a star high school baseball player.
He has been diagnosed with Mono, and must remain in bed for several weeks.
His father, a professional writer, gives him a book that teaches the form
and structure of poetry. Kevin decides to keep a journal to pass time,
and does so experimenting with different forms of poetry. His writing
becomes sensitive and introspective where topics range from baseball to
girls to his sorrow over the death of his mother. A good quick read.
I, Jack by Jack the dog (as told to Patricia
Finney)(4)
At first, I questioned the premise - a book written in the voice of a
dog? Ultimately, I found the book funny and "believable". The
author has captured what might be a canine's voice. Even cat lovers will
find this book fun as Jack's "funny-looking dog" friends add
their comments throughout the book in footnotes. The story is about Jack's
"pack", comprised of apedogs, and the love of his life, Petra,
the dog next door. Jack is often confused by the apedogs' behavior, but
is always loyal. He soon discovers that he will be the master of his own
pack and meets the challenge of his responsibilites.
Tree Girl by Ben Mikaelsen (4)
Gabriela, a native Mayan living in Guatemala, loves to climb trees. She
is intelligent, talented and has a bright future. Gabriela's story turns
violent and heart wrenching when her family, village and country are torn
apart by upheaval and violence. Her ability to climb trees saves her life,
but also creates conflict for her. This is a true story as told by the
real Gabriela to the author. The author does not attempt to sanitize the
story, which might make the story difficult for some. I found her story
incredibly sad, but an affirmation of the human spirit.
One of Those Hideous Book Where the Mother Dies
by Sonia Sones (5)
Many of you are familiar with Ms. Sones' free verse writing style. This
story, while written in the same style, is a departure from Stop Pretending
or What My Mother Doesn't Know. A story that reads like a screenplay,
the reader quickly becomes involved in the story's two sides: Hollywood
fairy tale and overcoming greif. Ruby's mother has passed away, forcing
her to move from Boston to L.A. to live in the mansion of her famous actor/father.
She is angry and resentful. She misses all that she has left behind -
family, friends and first loves. She is painfully greiving the loss of
her mother. Her greif blinds her to all that her new life affords - living
out the Hollywood fantasy. While the story is resolved neatly, there are
some twists that many of you will predict early on. Most will read this
in one sitting - it's that good!
|